
The red soles of Louboutins, the Burberry Check, the Hermès orange, and the little black dress by Chanel are all signature products we immediately associate with these high-end brands. But what stops other brands from copying these products? Or what can these brands do to stop other brands from copying these products? In this article, I will compare two different legal systems, the UK and the US legal systems, and explain how fashion trademarking works in each of them.
In my last article, I wrote about fast fashion; a part of this business model is copying clothes from the runway and rapidly and cost-effective replication. Unsurprisingly, there have been many trademark disputes in which a fast fashion brand was involved. In 2017, the high-end brand Gucci sent a cease-and-desist to the fast fashion brand Forever 21. Gucci accused Forever 21 of copying the brand’s signature “blue-red-blue” and “green-red-green” stripes on bomber jackets, sweaters, and chokers. This led to a court trial, which ended in December 2018; Gucci and Forever 21 settled out of court, ensuring Gucci kept its trademark for the stripes intact while Forever 21 had to remove the items from the store.
Unregistered design right in the UK
If you design apparel, you automatically have an unregistered design right; this means without a formal registration process or fees.
The SUD (Supplementary Unregistered Design) protects the overall appearance of your apparel, colors, patterns, and geographic prints. If you design a skirt with a special geographic design, the SUD is what protects its visual style, for 3 years after you first presented it to the public.The UKDR (UK Design Right) only protects the 3D form, silhouette or a special shape of a product. A normal T-shirt would get no protection under the UKDR, but if you design an asymmetric, specially shaped gown, the UKDR would protect this shape up to 15 years from creation.
Registered design right in the UK
If a design is registered through the UK Intellectual Property Office, a creation is provided with longer-lasting and stronger protection. This protection covers the 2D and 3D appearance, patterns, graphic designs, silhouettes, and colors all at the same time. After you showcase the designs, you have exactly 12 months to register them in the UK. The protection lasts up to 25 years, but you have to pay for registration, between £ 80 and £ 110.
The International Nice Classification System
The USPTO (United States Patent and Trademark Office) uses three classes to categorize fashion and design goods: Class 3, Class 25, and Class 35. This system has been used in the US since the 19th Century; there are 45 categories to differentiate different types of products.If your brand falls into one of these classes, it protects your brand from the likelihood of confusion but not from design copying.
Class 25 United States Patent and Trademark Office
Trademark Class 25 includes: Sport caps and hats and headwear (shower caps, berets, skull caps, etc.), Clothing (all kinds of clothing, jackets, gloves, dresses, vests, etc.), footwear (sports shoes, sandals, wooden shoes, etc)
Class 35 United States Patent and Trademark Office
Trademark Class 35 includes: Advertising, marketing and promotional services, public relations, product demonstrations, trade show and exhibition services, Provision of advertising space, time and media, Distribution of advertising, marketing, and promotional material, Advertising, marketing and promotional consultancy, Commercial trading and consumer information services, Retail and wholesale store services, Auctioneering services, Rental of vending machines, Business management and administration assistance, Accountancy, bookkeeping, auditing, Data processing, Human resources management and recruitment services, Clerical services, Business consultancy and advisory services, Rental of office machinery and equipment, Business analysis, research, and information services, Market research, Collection and systematization of written communications and data.
Class 3 United States Patent and Trademark Office
Trademark Class 3 includes: Cosmetics and personal care (Skincare, Make-Up, hair care, deodorants), cleaning preparations (surface cleaners, polishing products, fabric bleaches, etc.), Perfumery and Fragrances (Perfumes, essential oils, body mists, etc.), oral and hygiene products (tooth pastes, soaps, dental cleaning, etc)Likelihood of confusion
Likelihood of confusion is a key method in trademark law in the US which finds out if customers would confuse a product that is accused of being copied with the actual product. If a court finds that there is likelihood of confusion, it may decide that trademark infringement has occurred.
The Polaroid factors
The U.S. Court of Appeals uses the Polaroid Factors to assess the likelihood of confusion between two products; these are as follows…
1.Similarity of the marks: Courts consider the overall similarity between the trademarks,How similar the marks are in meaning, sound, and appearance.
2.Similarity of the goods: Is there overlap in the products which are being sold? This increases the likelihood of confusion.
3.Evidence of actual confusion: In this factor, courts consider if people have already mistaken the goods for the other one.
4.Overlap in marketing channels: Selling through the same online pages or stores (for example, Sephora) increases the chances of people mistaking one brand for another.
5.Sophistication of the consumers in the actual market: Courts consider how careful and sophisticated an average buyer of the product is; sophisticated buyers are less likely to confuse two different products.
6.Quality of the defendant’s products: If the allegedly copied product is of poor quality, because it can harm the original brand.
7.Intent of alleged infringer: For this factor, the court considers whether the defendant’s mark attempted to mimic another brand or if they adopted a trademark in good faith.
8.Strength of the mark: The more well-known the original brand is, the more legal protection it receives.
What happens if a product is actually copied?
The penalties vary significantly, spanning from mild sanctions like trademark takedowns or storefront bans to more severe cases with consequences such as attorney fees or prison time.
I hope you’ve enjoyed reading this article, unfortunately I wasn’t able to put the whole trademark law into one article, but I encourage everyone to do their own research on this topic if you’re interested in a part which I haven’t covered. It’s very hard to fully protect a product, especially for a start-up in the industry, but I’m certain that it’s very important to make sure no one steals amazing ideas!






